 | Colorado. Supreme Court - 1900 - 990 páginas
...such that reasonable men might fairly differ upon the question as to whether there was contributory negligence or not, the determination of the matter...only where the facts are such that all reasonable men would draw the same conclusion from them that the question becomes one of law for the court. As concisely... | |
 | New Hampshire. Supreme Court - 1900 - 698 páginas
.... When a given state of facts is such that reasonable men may fairly differ upon the question as to whether there was negligence or not, the determination of the matter is for the jury. It is only when the facts are such that reasonable men must draw the same conclusion from them, that the question... | |
 | 1900 - 812 páginas
...NEGLIGENCE — WHEN A QUESTION OP LAW FOR THE COURT. The question of negligence Is one of law for the court only where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusions from them. A case should not be withdrawn from the Jury unless the conclusion follows as... | |
 | 1900 - 1230 páginas
...affairs. When a given state of facts Is such that reasonable men may fairly differ upon the question as to whether there was negligence or not, the determination of the matter 'Is for the JuryIt Is only where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusion from... | |
 | 1900 - 902 páginas
...Negligence is never considered a question of law for the court, unless the facts shown by the evidence are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusion from a consideration of them, or are such as would warrant the court in setting aside the verdict of the... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1901 - 1416 páginas
...question as to whether there was negligence or not, the determination of the matter is for the )<iry. It is only where the facts are such that all reasonable...negligence is ever considered as one of law for the court." Grand Trunk B, Co. v. Ivee. 144 U. 8. 408, 417 [36: 485, 489]. We find no error of law to the prejudice... | |
 | John Milton Gardner, Walter James Eagle - 1901 - 800 páginas
...charge. In the case of Railroad Co. v. Ives, 144 US 408, 417, 12 Sup. Ct. Rep. 679, 683, the court said: "It is only where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusions from them that the question of negligence is ever considered one of law for the court."... | |
 | 1901 - 914 páginas
...of Railroad Co. v. Ives, 144 US 408, 417, 12 Sup. Ct. 679, 683, 36 L. Ed. 485, 489, the court said: "It is only where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusions from them tliat the question of negligence is ever considered one of law for the court."... | |
 | 1902 - 1142 páginas
...defendant was proper." Kane v. Railroad Co., 128 US 91. 04, 9 Sup. Ot 17, 32 L. Ed. 341. "It Is only whore the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw...negligence is ever considered as one of law for the court." Railroad Co. v. Ivés, 144 US 427, 12 Sup. Ct 683, 38 L. Ed. 489. "In determining whether the plaintiff... | |
 | Philip Taylor Van Zile - 1902 - 856 páginas
...In Gardner v. Railroad Co.* the court say : " The question of negligence is one of law for the court only where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusion from them, or, in other words, a case should not be withdrawn from the jury unless the conclusion follows as matter... | |
| |
When a given state of facts is such that reasonable men may fairly differ upon the question as to whether there was negligence or not, the determination of the matter is for the jury. It is only where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw... 
