 | 1922 - 956 páginas
...158 Ala. 381, 388, 48 South. 93. Concisely stated, the question is one of law for the court only when the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusion froui them, and for the jury when the state of facts is such that reasonable minds may fairly differ... | |
 | 1915 - 1346 páginas
...Justice Neill, in Railway v. Tirres, cited: "The question of negligence is one of law for the court only where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the вате conclusion from them. A case should not be withdrawn from the jury unless the conclusion follows,... | |
 | 1902 - 812 páginas
...affairs. When a given state of facts is such that reasonable men may fairly differ upon the question as to whether there was negligence or not, the determination of the matter is for the jury. Railroad Co. v. Ives, 144 U. S. 408, 12 Sup. Ct. 679, 36 L. Ed. 485; Railroad Co. v. Griffith, 159... | |
 | United States. Supreme Court - 1892 - 760 páginas
...2. When a given state of facts is such that reasonable men may fairly differ upon the question as to whether there was negligence or not, the determination of the matter is for the jury; but where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusion from them, the question... | |
 | 1900 - 810 páginas
...such evidence has been presented as makes it proper to submit the case to the jury. It is only when the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusions from them that the question of negligence becomes one of law for the court. Railway Co.... | |
 | Oklahoma. Supreme Court, Edward Bell Green, Frank Dale, John Henry Burford, Robert Lee Williams, Matthew John Kane, Howard J. Parker, Charles Winfield Van Eaton - 1912 - 938 páginas
...affairs. When a given state of facts is such that reasonable men may fairly differ upon the question as to whether there was negligence or not, the determination...negligence is ever considered as one of law for the court." See Sans Bois Coal Co. v. Jancu'ay, 22 Okla. 425, 99 Pac. 153 ; St. Louis & SFR Co. r. Copland, :>:5... | |
 | Oklahoma. Supreme Court, Edward Bell Green, Frank Dale, John Henry Burford, Robert Lee Williams, Matthew John Kane, Howard J. Parker, Charles Winfield Van Eaton - 1917 - 912 páginas
...Wis. 524. Questions of negligence do not become questions of law, to be decided by the court, except where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw the same conclusion from them, and the case should not be withdrawn from the jury unless the conclusion follows, as a matter of law,... | |
| |
When a given state of facts is such that reasonable men may fairly differ upon the question as to whether there was negligence or not, the determination of the matter is for the jury. It is only where the facts are such that all reasonable men must draw... 
